Nov

7

Better Late Than Never


Posted by at 6:30 pm on November 7, 2007
Category: General

Village in Southern SudanLast week, on October 31, the Office of Foreign Assets Control issued a final rule amending the Sudanese Sanctions to permit exports to the semi-autonomous region of Southern Sudan. These rules implemented Executive Order 13412 issued by the White House on October 13, 2006 which exempted Southern Sudan from the sanctions imposed on Sudan by Executive Order 13067.

Apparently because OFAC’s regulations weren’t revised for almost a year after Executive Order 13412 lifted the export ban for Southern Sudan, OFAC’s staff was insisting that licenses were still required for transactions in Southern Sudan and either weren’t granting them or were granting them after long delays. According to this wire report yesterday from Reuters:

Until now U.S. organisations have still had to go through long procedures with OFAC to get around the 1997 order. “To get an exemption from the comprehensive sanctions imposed in November 1997 was virtually impossible,” added Sudan specialist Eric Reeves, who has been trying to set up schools in the south despite “extremely onerous” regulations. “In some fundamental sense only now have sanctions really been lifted on the south,” Reeves added. …

“It should have been clear from day one that the south would be exempted from the sanctions,” said Sudan expert John Prendergast, currently with the Enough Project. He said the period of confusion arose from what he called U.S. government ineptness.

An interesting anomaly persists in the new regulations. The amended regulations of added a new subsection (g) to the list of exempt transactions in 31 C.F.R. § 538.12 (formerly § 538.11). Subsection (g)(1) exempts transactions in the “Specified Areas of Sudan” which are defined to include large parts of Southern Sudan. However, section (g)(2) says that the exemption in (g)(1) doesn’t apply to food, medicine and medical devices. Apparently, as I read this, you could ship a ton of bricks to Southern Sudan without a license to Sudan, but to send food and life-saving medicines you still need to undergo the delay and expense of a license. That doesn’t seem to make a whole lot of sense, but I haven’t gone back to see if there is some legislative justification for this in either the Trade Sanctions Reform Act, which governs exports of agricultural products, medicine and medical devices, or in the initial legislation which led to Executive Order 13067.

Permalink

Bookmark and Share

Copyright © 2007 Clif Burns. All Rights Reserved.
(No republication, syndication or use permitted without my consent.)


4 Comments:


This reveals an inconsistency, typical of OFAC: Where OFAC has failed to issue regulations in a timely fashion after Executive Orders were issued (think Iraq, Iran), OFAC has maintained that exporters were still bound by the Executive Orders as later interpreted by OFAC; but, now, when the Executive Order actually deregulates something, OFAC claims it ain’t over until they sing.

Comment by Mike Deal on November 7th, 2007 @ 8:37 pm

Im trying to drill a well in southern sudan this next year for a doctor friend whom has a clinic but little water for her patients. I will fly in from Nairobi on a charter. What paperwork and or lic. do we need to fly from Kenya to a remote village in southern Sudan and hand bore a well. we will fly in all of our supplies, ie pump,solar panels, well casing and plumbing supplies. There are no government officials in the area and we will be there only 10 days. I would hate to have this fail because our government or theirs dont have their ducks in a row. Anyone have some ideas? Im doing this out of pocket with a few corporate helpers.

Comment by grant fairbanks on November 8th, 2007 @ 5:49 pm

Grant, although I appreciate the humanitarian aspect of your project, we can’t provide legal advice on this blog relating to specific cases. Nor can we permit others to do so in the comments section. DC Bar Rules require a retainer agreement to provide legal advice to a company or individual on a specific case involving that company or individual

However, if you want to give me a call and give me some more information on the project, I may be able to have our pro bono committee approve our taking the case without a fee. My number is under the contact tab. Other lawyers who read this blog may also be willing to do the same, and if there are any of you, please speak up.

Comment by Clif Burns on November 8th, 2007 @ 8:38 pm

Grant at Fairbanks,

I suggest you contact OFAC for guidance. Best way is to write them a letter explaining what you want to do and ask if you need a license. More information you provide in the letter the quicker the response. Also, check out the OFAC website: http://www.treas.gov/offices/enforcement/ofac. Good luck.

Sudan watcher in DC

Comment by Lee Miller on November 9th, 2007 @ 12:36 pm